"Armeyskaya Seriya 50: BMP: Boyevaya
Mashina Sovetskoy Pekhoty" (Army Series 50: BMP: Soviet Infantry Combat Vehicle)
by Ye. V. Yegers (Editor)
S
u m m a r y
|
Title, Description,
Publisher, Media and Price |
"Armeyskaya Seriya 50: BMP: Boyevaya
Mashina Sovetskoy Pekhoty" (Army Series 50: BMP: Soviet Infantry Combat
Vehicle) by Ye. V. Yegers (Editor), translated into Russian by G. B.
Brylevskiy; Tornado Publications, Riga, Latvia, 1998; 52 pp. plus color
covers; price $10 via East View Publications |
Review Type: |
FirstRead |
Advantages: |
None |
Disadvantages: |
Only for non-English speaking native
Russian speakers |
Recommendation: |
Not Recommended - buy the Osprey/New
Vanguard version instead |
Reviewed by
Cookie Sewell
HyperScale is proudly supported by Squadron.com
I am usually pretty tolerant of people that borrow a bit here and there when
they put a book together, but have little use for the total theft of
intellectual property rights. This book is another in a long line of examples of
fast-buck work from the former USSR in which someone translates a book from a
known author into Russian, scans in some photos and artwork from books or off
the internet, and then publishes under his own name.
At least Mr. Yegers does not claim authorship, which is good; this particular
book is a verbatim copy of the Steve Zaloga/Peter Sarson New Vanguard Number 12
published in 1994. It adds in some sketches of the BMP vehicles which, based on
the disclaimer at the front of the book, were "freely accessible on the
Internet" as it insinuates the text and photos were. Unfortunately since I am
fluent in my Russian comprehension this work only qualifies as what Canadian
author Barry Beldam refers to as "outright theft."
There are a large number of reputable Russian authors like Svirin, Baryatinskiy,
Shirokorad, Kovshchevskiy and Kolomiets, but this lot from Riga will not join
their ranks by simply swiping and translating others' materials.
Cookie Sewell
Review Copyright © 2004 by Cookie
Sewell
Page Created 03 March, 2004
Last updated 03 March, 2004
Back to HyperScale
Main Page
Back to Reviews
Page
|
|